routing asymmetrically with wild card L4 VS

I have created a traffic group that includes a selfIP to the server network (F5 is the default gateway) and another to the network connecting the F5 to the rest of the data center network. The servers (Exchange) need to talk to AD, for example, and I would like them to route out to a different network then the default route. I created a wild card layer 4 VS pointing to a pool with the member being the next hop route interface. I believe that I am now routing asymmetrically and AD is failing. Node comes up, I can ping, etc. Thoughts on where to start breaking this down?

Thanks