Forum Discussion

Angel_Lopez_116's avatar
Angel_Lopez_116
Icon for Altostratus rankAltostratus
Dec 01, 2014

How is choosen the master or primary slot of the cluster?

Hi there,

I'd like to know how the cluster master slot is choosen? Is there any rule or algorithm to choose the primary slot on boot?

I'm wondering why my Viprion has decided this configuration after booting:

On the vCMP host:

-----------------------------------------
Sys::Cluster: default
-----------------------------------------
Address                 192.168.16.32/21
Availability            available
State                   enabled
Reason                  Cluster Enabled
Primary Slot ID         1
Primary Selection Time  11/27/14 09:03:31

  ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  | Sys::Cluster Members
  | ID  Address        Availability  State     Licensed  HA       Clusterd  Reason
  ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  | 1   192.168.16.33  available     enabled   true      active   running   Run
  | 2   192.168.16.34  available     enabled   true      active   running   Run
  | 3   ::             unknown       disabled  false     unknown  shutdown  Slot powered off or empty, manually disabled
  | 4   ::             unknown       disabled  false     unknown  shutdown  Slot powered off or empty, manually disabled

On the guest:

-----------------------------------------
Sys::Cluster: default
-----------------------------------------
Address                 192.168.16.55/21
Availability            available
State                   enabled
Reason                  Cluster Enabled
Primary Slot ID         2
Primary Selection Time  11/27/14 09:06:27

  ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  | Sys::Cluster Members
  | ID  Address  Availability  State    Licensed  HA       Clusterd  Reason
  ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  | 1   ::       available     enabled  true      active   running   Run
  | 2   ::       available     enabled  true      active   running   Run
  | 3   ::       unknown       enabled  false     unknown  shutdown  Slot powered off or empty
  | 4   ::       unknown       enabled  false     unknown  shutdown  Slot powered off or empty

I'd expect to see the guest active on slot 1 too, how is this?

It doesn't matter that the slot 1 is the active one for the host and slot 2 for the guest?

8 Replies

  • It doesn't matter which blade is chosen as the primary for either the vCMP host or vCMP guest. If you had more blades and more guests its entirely possible to have the primary of all of them be different. As to how that decision is made, I have not found documentation on that, though through observations it appears it generally chooses the first available slot but don't quote me on that. It may choose the least busy, but I honestly couldn't say for sure.

     

    • Angel_Lopez_116's avatar
      Angel_Lopez_116
      Icon for Altostratus rankAltostratus
      So the primary role is just to set the source from which the system will be replicated to a new blade, right? It doesn't have any other relevance.
    • Brad_Parker's avatar
      Brad_Parker
      Icon for Cirrus rankCirrus
      "When the cluster initializes, one blade is determined to be the primary blade and all other blades are secondary blades. In addition to processing traffic like other blades, the primary blade is a management blade, which sets and maintains the configuration for the whole cluster." https://support.f5.com/kb/en-us/solutions/public/10000/700/sol10778.html?sr=29127145
  • It doesn't matter which blade is chosen as the primary for either the vCMP host or vCMP guest. If you had more blades and more guests its entirely possible to have the primary of all of them be different. As to how that decision is made, I have not found documentation on that, though through observations it appears it generally chooses the first available slot but don't quote me on that. It may choose the least busy, but I honestly couldn't say for sure.

     

    • Angel_Lopez_116's avatar
      Angel_Lopez_116
      Icon for Altostratus rankAltostratus
      So the primary role is just to set the source from which the system will be replicated to a new blade, right? It doesn't have any other relevance.
    • Brad_Parker_139's avatar
      Brad_Parker_139
      Icon for Nacreous rankNacreous
      "When the cluster initializes, one blade is determined to be the primary blade and all other blades are secondary blades. In addition to processing traffic like other blades, the primary blade is a management blade, which sets and maintains the configuration for the whole cluster." https://support.f5.com/kb/en-us/solutions/public/10000/700/sol10778.html?sr=29127145
  • I'm not 100% sure, but I think it's whatever blade boots up faster and gets it's services running. On mine I noticed, if Slot1 is primary, then you reboot the chassis, the secondary blades reboot faster. So after the next reboot Slot2 will be primary.

     

    • Angel_Lopez_116's avatar
      Angel_Lopez_116
      Icon for Altostratus rankAltostratus
      I see... it seems that there's no rule to decide who will be the master.