Getting TCP Reset-0 from server when routing HTTPS traffic via F5

We would like to place the working public URL behind the F5. The current connection works similarly to a firewall NATing a public IP address to a private one before sending it to the server. We placed F5 between the server and firewall. On the Firewall, a new route has been added and on F5 we have new VIP and pool. Both VIP and Pool are active. However, we are unable to hit the page by saying "ERR_CONNECTION_RESET". The logs indicate that the connection from the F5 NAT IP to the server was broken down using a TCP connection with a duration of 0:00:00 bytes 1697 TCP Reset-O from the F5_Interface.

I added the port 443 as the pool monitor, and the logs indicate that the monitor connection teardown was successful. I also attempted to telnet using port 443 to this public IP address, and that also worked. Please, if anyone can help me with this.